IS DYNAMIC TIME SLOT MANAGEMENT REALLY A USEFUL SOLUTION FOR TRAFFIC JAMS IN THE FACTORY?
07/05/2019 Oliver Graf
Headerbild: Milos Muller/shutterstock.com
Time slot booking offers forwarders and manufacturing companies a straightforward way to intelligently control their truck deliveries and pick-ups, while avoiding delays and long truck turnaround times at the plant due to delayed material or traffic jams. An intelligent time slot management system centrally manages the loading points and the necessary capacities, thus optimizing resource utilization not only at the plant level, but also down to each loading point for incoming and outgoing goods, if required.
For some time now, dynamic time slot management has been an issue in the logistics industry. For this purpose, the systems are linked to tracking systems that track the trucks in real time and therefore have precise information about the location of the vehicles and their arrival at the plant. A dynamic arrival time calculation automatically and precisely transmits the arrival time of the trucks to the ramp operator within a booked time slot. The theory behind it: If the truck does not arrive on time (or does), the new arrival time is transmitted directly to the system and the plant. Traffic jams that are difficult to predict or similar incidents that can quickly lead to delays are automatically taken into account. The aim of this approach is to have the flexibility to respond quickly to delays.
For time slot system operators and forwarders this sounds like a plausible solution- a very tempting one too. Continuous system synchronization offers reduced data maintenance and ensures that data is always up to date. However, this approach has its limitations. Peak times, such as midday retail, cannot be intercepted with this booking method. This is because dynamic time slots cannot regularize peak times for deliveries and pick-ups. Just because a time slot is dynamic doesn't mean it won’t fall right into a rush hour.
Even if all time slots were immediately adapted to the new Estimated Time of Arrival (ETA),it could still lead to traffic jams in front of the plant and at the loading points. The trucks can still arrive at the same time; for example, even if a forwarder is late, he can in fact no longer miss his time slot. Consequently, neither rush hours nor traffic jams are prevented.
However, this isn’t sufficient enough to solve the traffic problem. Adapting the time slots to the current situation alone does not allow efficient truck handling. This is only one aspect of a good and practical solution. It is also important to handle the arriving trucks on the basis of a set of rules and their priorities in real time, in order to ensure a transparent and fair handling process with the shortest possible waiting and throughput times- even in congested situations. Apart from transparency regarding the actual time of arrival, nothing else has been gained.
A rectification and reduction of waiting and throughput times is therefore only possible if the trucks are handled according to their order of priority. In addition to the time slot duration, this can be determined by a variety of other criteria, such as
- the material to be collected or delivered and the corresponding adherence to production and delivery dates
- contractual agreements with the forwarding agents (e.g. demurrage agreements),
- the importance of the customer or supplier behind the delivery,
- the number of loading points to be reached,
- the overall process, which in addition to loading can also include activities such as weighing or checklist procedures.
These few examples alone demonstrate how many influencing factors play a role in the truck handling of a commercial or industrial enterprise and how complex the loading and unloading process can be when trying to achieve the shortest possible waiting and handling times.
Intelligent solutions based on Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Operations Research (OR) methods are able to take into account the multitude of influencing factors according to their respective weighting offer real added value. They combine ETA information with knowledge- and rule-based AI and OR methods, thus enabling an efficient overall process in which not only the expected arrival time, but also supplementary parameters such as the ones described above are intelligently taken into account. Like an autopilot, these systems control the entire process in real time, so that manual intervention in loading area management is only necessary in exceptional cases.
Among other things, the basic principle of these intelligent control systems is thatreal time control only takes a truck into account after it arrives, and in the case of a delayed arrival, trucks are given a lower priority. It is important to note that this does not automatically mean that these trucks are continuously pushed to the end of the waiting loop, since intelligent control systems can dynamically re-integrate these trucks back into the overall process. As the waiting time increases, the priority of these trucks increases again, to guarantee an efficient overall process. When ETA calculations clearly indicate early on that a truck will not reach its booked time slot on time, the system takes the subsequent changes directly into account. For example, by bringing forward the time slot for another truck that has already arrived.
There are various approaches to intelligently planning truck supply control and time slot management. Although the dynamic time slot booking approach maps the current situation of the trucks, it does not prevent peak times in the plant and therefore does not reduce waiting times. Since peak times are not avoided by dynamic time slots, they do not, in my opinion, offer a potential solution for traffic jams in and around the plant. It makes more sense to flexibly optimize the time slots according to the real conditions in the plant. Only then can long waiting times be brought to an end.
How are time slots booked in your company? What approach do you take to optimizing your truck supply control?